Carving Sword is the 18th most-used weapon under the current filters (1.2% of 49,532 recorded fights), winning 47.5% overall - 16.0% of its wins come against better-geared opponents.
Best against Galatine Pair (40.0%), Bloodletter (38.2%), Realmbreaker (37.0%). Struggles against Battle Bracers (18.8%), Spiked Gauntlets (25.9%), Longbow (28.2%).
Winrate by IP difference (50-IP buckets, dot size = sample size). A flat curve means the weapon carries regardless of gear; a steep one means it only wins when out-gearing.